Nonprofit Storytelling Techniques for Effective Email Marketing

A picture of a cute dog on a webpage, in an email, and on a donation form.

Erin Booker

•

March 31, 2025

•

6 minutes

Nonprofit Trends

Donor Communications

This article is part of a series

Keep learning with related articles.

Soon..

In this digital age, where inboxes overflow with appeals, nonprofits face the challenge of cutting through the noise to connect with donors. Storytelling isn’t just a buzzword—it’s the secret weapon for transforming transactional emails into emotional journeys that drive engagement and donations. But there's a secret to success: by weaving narratives that highlight real impact, nonprofits can turn supporters into lifelong advocates.

Funraise’s Bulk Email Messaging tool, baked directly into your fundraising CRM, empowers organizations to deliver these stories with surgical precision, ensuring the right message reaches the right donor at the right moment. Take a tour with us through your inbox and discover nonprofit email marketing tips to harness storytelling techniques and technology to turn your email campaigns into fundraising powerhouses.

Understanding the importance of storytelling in nonprofits

Storytelling is the backbone of human connection, and for nonprofits, it’s the bridge between mission and action. While facts inform, stories inspire—a principle validated by neuroscience: narratives activate brain regions linked to empathy and memory, making supporters more likely to donate.

Consider this: A donor receives two emails. One states,

“Your $50 donation provides clean water.”

The other shares Kim's journey—a woman in North Korea who's just 50 miles away from the freedom of a new life in the United States.

"Imagine being 50 mi away from freedom and needing $10 to get there. Kim is so close to a new life: Donate $10 toward her escape.

Which email compels action? The answer lies in emotional resonance, a storytelling superpower that turns statistics into soul-stirring experiences.

Funraise’s integrated approach ensures these stories don’t get lost in the shuffle. With real-time donor data updates, your emails automatically reflect the latest impact metrics, keeping narratives fresh and relevant.

Crafting compelling narratives

So now that you're fired up about infusing your emails with stories, let's talk about how you can git 'er dun.

Identifying key characters and settings

Every great story needs a protagonist. In nonprofit emails, this role is shared between your beneficiaries (like Kim), your donors (the heroes), and your organization (the guide). Use specificity to ground your narrative:

Beneficiary Spotlight: “Meet Jamal, a 14-year-old who tutored 30 of his peers last month using your donated textbooks.”
Donor as Hero: “Because of you, 12 families avoided eviction this winter.”

Funraise’s segmentation tools let you tailor these details based on donor history. A monthly supporter might receive a story about sustained impact, while an event attendee gets a narrative tied to their participation.

Utilizing real-world examples

Real talk: Authenticity trumps polish. Share raw, unfiltered moments:

“When the LA fires hit, Carla’s café became a soup kitchen. Your $100 gift? It kept her stove running for 72 straight hours, serving 1,200 meals.”

Embed photos or link to short videos directly into Funraise emails to add visceral depth. As Justin Wheeler, Funraise CEO, notes:

“Donors don’t just fund causes—they fund transformations they can see”.

Creating emotional connections

Leverage the SUCCESs model (Simple, Unexpected, Concrete, Credible, Emotional, Stories):

Simple: Focus on one beneficiary per email.
Unexpected: “She expected homelessness. You gave her a surprise move-in date.”
Concrete: “$73 = 30 meals” → “Your gift fills 30 plates like these (photo of a family’s Thanksgiving table).”

Funraise’s automated impact updates let you insert real-time data:

“You’ve helped 8 more students graduate since last month!”.

Trending techniques that emphasize impact

Personalizing donor experiences

Tailoring messages to individual donors

Gone are the days of “Dear [First Name]” as peak personalization. With Funraise’s CRM integration, emails can reference:

Donation history: “Your 3rd gift this year just funded a week of mentorship!”
Event attendance: “Remember the joy at last year’s gala? Here’s what happened next…”
Geographic data: “Meet a neighbor your gift supported…”

The impact of personalization on engagement

Segment your list into:

Loyal Donors: Stories about legacy (“You’ve changed 300 lives since 2020”).
Lapsed Donors: Nostalgic narratives (“Remember when you helped build this school?”).
Volunteers: Impact-through-action messages (“Your 8 hours taught 30 kids to read”).

Funraise’s real-time lists ensure segments stay updated, so a donor who just lapsed won’t receive a loyalty story by mistake.

What the experts have to say about story-focused email campaigns

Here are a couple of hot takes on storytelling. Good stuff to keep in mind.

"A fundraising story is a vignette; it's a snapshot, not a full view. What you say matters, but also what you leave out matters."

— Olga M. Woltman, on the Nonstop Nonprofit podcast that is literally called "How nonprofits can use stories that strengthen connections".

"Ethical storytelling shifts energy; people feel heard, seen, and understand their stories matter."

– Ashley Gutierrez, in another Nonstop Nonprofit podcast episode all about storytelling.

Funraise CEO Justin Wheeler adds:

“Automation isn’t about replacing humanity—it’s about scaling it. Our tools let you send endless emails that each feel hand-picked.”

And obviously, we have lots to say about storytelling. If you're jonesing for more, take a look at these articles:

People-powered storytelling with Olga M. Woltman
How to tell your nonprofit story through quotes
8 Proven Nonprofit Fundraising Strategies (Yeah, we know it sounds generic, but try looking at these strategies through a storytelling lens.)

Best practices for nonprofit email campaigns

Optimizing for mobile platforms

The vast majority of donation emails are opened on phones. Funraise’s responsive templates ensure mobile optimization through:

Customizable layouts
Variable font sizes
Thumb-friendly CTA buttons

Test using the 3-second rule: If a supporter can’t grasp the story’s core in one scroll, simplify.

Segmenting your audience lists

Beyond basic demographics, segment by:

Engagement Level: Open/click history
Donation Type: Recurring vs. one-time
Interest Area: Education vs. healthcare donors

Once set up, Funraise’s tagging system automates this, sending marathon fundraiser updates to runners and gala stories to event attendees.

Ensuring compliance with regulations

GDPR and CAN-SPAM aren’t just legal checkboxes—they’re trust-builders. Here's our standard wake-up call regarding email compliance:

Fair warning about email lists: while we think marketing emails are very excellent (just look at our newsletter!), there are both written laws and unwritten rules in place regarding use and security of personal data. These laws and rules affect what you can do with email addresses, including whether you can send marketing emails. GDPR covers digital privacy regulations in Europe, CCPA covers the same in California, and CASL covers spam and electronic threats in Canada. Read up on them if you're in the mood to be confused. We can't offer advice on compliance, but we can tell you that reputable ESPs like Mailchimp and Constant Contact know what they're doing, so tap into their expertise. And most importantly, don't buy or sell email lists!

Benefit to using Funraise: Real-time list updates prevent emails to unsubscribed contacts.

How to use technology to turn your emails into fundraising fire 🔥

Funraise’s Bulk Email Messaging transforms storytelling from art to science

Automated Impact Updates

Connect your CRM so every donation triggers a story about its ripple effect.

Dynamic Content Blocks

Show different beneficiary stories based on donor location or interests.

A/B Testing

Pit two story angles against each other. Does “Meet the Student” outperform “Your Gift at Work”?

Here's a (made up, but still illustrative) example: A wildlife nonprofit uses Funraise’s geo-targeting to send localized stories. Donors in coastal states receive sea turtle rescue updates, while inland supporters see forest conservation wins.

But did you know that the rest of your fundraising tools can lend a hand? Try these ideas on for size:

Donation Forms

Engaging storytelling in your emails can significantly boost your donation form conversions, which already average an impressive 50% with Funraise.

Recurring Giving

By telling compelling stories, you can inspire donors to commit to recurring giving, ensuring sustained support for your nonprofit's mission.

Peer-to-peer Fundraising

Incorporating powerful personal narratives in your emails can amplify the impact of peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns. And don't get us started on the effect of your fundraisers' stories in their appeals to their networks.

Automated Emails

Pairing nonprofit automated email campaigns with authentic storytelling ensures timely and personalized donor engagement.

Reports & Dashboards

Use data-driven insights from custom reports and dashboards to refine your storytelling approach and measure its effectiveness.

Measuring success and impact

Defining Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

Track beyond dollars raised:

Engagement Rate: % of readers who click past the first narrative element.
Scroll Depth: How much of the story they read.
Social Shares: Emotional stories get forwarded more than generic appeals.

Analyzing engagement metrics

Funraise’s industry-leading reporting and dashboard tools answer your critical questions about your fundraising email campaigns:

When do stories resonate most? (Spoiler: 10 AM on Tuesdays for working donors, 7 PM for retirees.)
Which CTAs convert best?
How do emails with stories affect retention?

Case Studies: Successful storytelling campaigns

This is less a story about email and more like... a story about how storytelling beats the odds. But we encourage you to listen to Funraise CEO and Co-founder Justin Wheeler talk about a very special donor segment and how storytelling led to surprising success.

In the end, storytelling isn’t just about what you say—it’s about making donors the heroes of a narrative only they can continue. With Funraise’s tools, every email becomes a chapter in your supporters’ legacy.

Mobile phone with donation form and donation charts floating around the phone.

Woman looking at fundraising chart with button to book a call.

Yellow shapes in background with donation form in front with stylized text, build an intelligence giving experience.

Download

Start For Free

Email Storytelling FAQ

How long should our story emails be?

As long as needed, but keep paragraphs under 3 lines. Use a free testing tool to test mobile readability—they're all over the internet, but some reliable ones are Litmus and Email on Acid.

Can we repurpose stories across channels?

Absolutely! Spin off Funraise email content directly to social posts or blog updates. Or vice versa; use a viral social post as the body of your email.

Who should I email?

Segment your email list based on donor history, interests, and engagement levels. Target past volunteers, event attendees, lapsed users, and specific demographics. Personalize content for each segment to increase relevance and engagement. Consider geographic location and donor status when crafting targeted messages.

What content should I send?

Focus on compelling storytelling that creates emotional connections. Share personal stories of beneficiaries, highlight your nonprofit's impact with data, and use vivid descriptions. Include updates on milestones, new programs, and upcoming events. Use photos and videos to enhance visual storytelling and engagement.

When should you send emails?

Optimal times vary by audience. Test different send times and analyze metrics to determine the best schedule for your specific supporters.

How can I improve email open rates?

Improve email open rates by using personalized subject lines, segmenting your audience, and optimizing for mobile devices. Ensure clear, compelling subject lines that highlight the story or impact. Use A/B testing to refine your approach and analyze metrics to identify successful strategies.

How do I measure email campaign success?

Measure email campaign success by tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) such as open rates, click-through rates (CTRs), conversion rates, and donor retention. Use metrics like story engagement rate and social shares to assess emotional impact. Analyze these metrics to refine future campaigns and enhance storytelling effectiveness.

What are effective subject lines for nonprofit emails?

Craft effective subject lines by focusing on storytelling elements: use names, highlight impact, and create urgency. Examples include "Meet Maria: Your Gift Changed Her Life" or "24 Hours to Fund 100 Meals." Personalization and emotional resonance can significantly boost open rates.

How often should I send fundraising emails?

Send fundraising emails based on your audience's engagement level and campaign goals. Generally, send emails when you have a compelling story or update, such as after a major event or milestone. Avoid over-emailing, which can lead to fatigue. Use automation to personalize frequency based on donor interactions.